WP Engine Accuses Automattic of Planning Royalties on 10 Competitors

WP Engine accuses Automattic of planning royalties on 10 competitors and of interfering with existing contracts.

WP Engine Accuses Automattic of Planning Royalties on 10 Competitors
WordPress and Automattic logo on an abstract background

The legal dispute between WP Engine and Automattic, the company founded by Matt Mullenweg, co-creator of WordPress, has recently taken on a new dimension. WP Engine has filed an updated complaint alleging that Automattic planned to impose royalties on at least ten other hosting providers besides WP Engine. It further claims that Mullenweg tried to pressure Stripe into cancelling its contract with WP Engine.

WP Engine's allegations

According to the complaint, Automattic identified ten competitors to be subjected to royalty demands for use of the WordPress trademark. Among them, Newfold, owner of Bluehost and HostGator, had reportedly already agreed to pay for use of the trademark. Other names were omitted from the complaint, but it refers to internal communications between Automattic and these companies.

The royalty question

At the heart of the dispute is Automattic's demand that WP Engine pay 8% of its gross monthly revenue as a royalty for use of the WordPress trademark. WP Engine disputes this figure, calling it arbitrary and based on an assessment of how much the company could afford to pay, as Mullenweg reportedly indicated at an event in 2024.

Interference with Stripe

Another allegation concerns Mullenweg's contact with a Stripe executive, in an alleged attempt to influence the cancellation of the contract between Stripe and WP Engine. This reportedly happened after WP Engine sued Automattic in 2024.

Reactions and implications

Automattic has rejected the allegations, describing WP Engine's complaint as a rehash of old claims already dismissed by the court. The company argues that WP Engine is trying to portray robust competition as something sinister and that the legal case has no merit.

Conclusion

  • Aggressive monetization strategy: Automattic reportedly planned to extend royalty demands to more competitors, increasing its revenue from the WordPress trademark.
  • Interference with existing contracts: The alleged intervention with Stripe points to a possible strategy to influence WP Engine's business relationships.
  • Controversy over the 8% royalty: The dispute over the amount demanded raises questions about the valuation and fairness of royalty demands.
  • WP Engine's resistance: WP Engine continues to contest Automattic's actions, seeking to protect its position in the WordPress hosting market.
  • Implications for the WordPress community: The conflict could affect the dynamics between companies operating in the WordPress ecosystem and their relationship with the open source community.

For more details, see the original article on TechCrunch.