Landmark Ruling Against Saudi Arabia for Use of Pegasus Spyware

The case of Ghanem Al-Masarir highlights the use of government spyware against activists and dissidents.

Landmark Ruling Against Saudi Arabia for Use of Pegasus Spyware
Ghanem Al-Masarir during a protest in London

On January 26, 2026, the High Court in London handed down a landmark ruling, ordering the Saudi government to pay more than 3 million pounds in damages to Ghanem Al-Masarir, a satirist and human rights activist living in London. The court found "compelling evidence" that his phone had been compromised with Pegasus spyware, sold exclusively to governments, and held that the attack had been "directed or authorized" by the Saudi government or its agents. The court also found that the Saudi government was probably responsible for a physical assault Al-Masarir suffered in London in 2018, a period when his phone had been compromised. This case is one of the rare occasions on which a court has recognized a state's responsibility for using spyware against a dissident abroad.

The Case of Ghanem Al-Masarir

Ghanem Al-Masarir, also known as Ghanem al-Dosari, is a Saudi satirist and human rights activist who gained notoriety for his criticism of the Saudi regime through his YouTube channel, which has racked up millions of views. In 2018, he discovered that his phone had been infected with Pegasus spyware, developed by the Israeli company NSO Group and sold exclusively to governments. Later in 2018, he was physically assaulted in London, an act he linked to the Saudi authorities. In 2019, Al-Masarir sued the Saudi government, accusing it of illegal surveillance and of being responsible for the physical assault he suffered. The court rejected the Saudi government's defense based on state immunity, allowing the case to proceed. In January 2026, the High Court issued its ruling, recognizing the Saudi government's responsibility and ordering compensation.

Implications for Cybersecurity and Human Rights

This case raises important questions about states' use of advanced surveillance tools against activists and dissidents. Pegasus software has been used in numerous documented cases to violate the privacy of individuals critical of authoritarian governments. The London High Court's ruling sets a significant precedent, indicating that states can be held responsible for using spyware against individuals abroad. This could influence future legal actions and policies on states' use of surveillance technologies.

Reactions and Future Prospects

Al-Masarir welcomed the ruling, saying that it "closes a long and painful chapter" and confirms that "defending the truth, no matter how powerful the opponent, is worth fighting for". He also stressed that, although no amount of money can undo what he has suffered, he hopes the Saudi government will now do the right thing and comply with the ruling without the need for further enforcement action. It is unclear whether Saudi Arabia will pay Al-Masarir or whether it intends to appeal the decision. A spokesperson for the Saudi embassy in Washington, D.C., did not immediately respond to a request for comment. This case could have significant implications for state accountability in the use of surveillance technologies and could influence international legislation and policy on privacy and human rights.

Takeaways

  • State responsibility for the use of spyware: The London High Court's ruling sets a precedent that states can be held responsible for using spyware against individuals abroad.
  • Implications for privacy and human rights: The case highlights concerns about authoritarian governments' use of advanced surveillance technologies against activists and dissidents.
  • Possible changes in international policy: The decision could influence future legal actions and policies on states' use of surveillance technologies, promoting greater accountability and transparency.
  • Impact on the international community: The ruling could encourage other individuals and organizations to take legal action against states' unlawful use of surveillance technologies.
  • Prospects for the protection of digital rights: The case underscores the importance of developing and enforcing international laws that protect individuals' privacy and digital rights against the abuse of surveillance technologies.